Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Deborah Bucknam's avatar

A gentle suggestion: please stop posting items that are not news. Today is an excellent example: the Catholic Bishop's statement about immigration. Of course, the NYT makes it a headline, but that doesn't make it news. The Bishop's text itself is full of platitudes, exaggerations, and conclusory statements, with not one fact listed in its condemnation to support its claims. Yet the NYT prints a story as if its fact, and you dutifully reprint it. Vilification of immigrants? who is vilifying immigrants? No one. Yes, Trump has harsh words to say about illegal immigrants, but the facts bear him out. Over 70% of the illegals deported have criminal records, some with serious felonies. Those are facts, which make it news. Not slander by the Bishops that Americans are bigoted and racist. (Yes, that is the defamatory implication--repeated over and over again for decades by the Elites. Certainly not news or new.) Indiscriminate deportations? What are the facts to support that wild claim? What expertise do the Bishops have to make that claim? They don't answer either question. The NYT has converted opinion by immigration non-experts to headline "news". Did the Bishops issue condemnation about the Biden Administration's immigration policy that allowed drugs to pour into our country killing our kids, because border enforcement men and women were too busy trying to process millions of illegals; or did they condemn the 350,000 minors the Biden administration lost because of the tsunami of illegal immigration? Uh, no. Sadly, "news" today is too often based on the logical fallacy of appeal to authority, even when the "authority" has no special expertise or facts to support its opinion. The Bishop's first statement reveals the logical fallacy: "As pastors, we the bishops of the United States are bound to our people by ties of communion and compassion in Our Lord Jesus Christ." That does not make their opinion factually correct, but they use it to imply their opinion is based on some special expertise or knowledge. Appeal to authority in today's "news" is almost always an elite group who opposes conservatives, Republicans, or President Trump. So, please stick to news. If you want to post opinions, that is fine; but I suggest you change your title from News Items to News and Opinion Items and separate the news from opinions. It will increase your credibility.

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts

Ready for more?